Wondering what dessert choices you can find at Wolter’s Shoreview Supper Club? The current online dessert menu lists four ways to finish a meal: Classic Sundaes, the Cake or Pie of the Evening, an Old-Fashioned Malt, and an à la mode option.
Each one suits a different kind of sweet craving. The guide below uses only items currently listed on Shoreview’s live menu. Because the evening’s selection and restaurant availability can change, ask your server or call ahead when a particular dessert matters to your visit.
Classic Sundaes
Shoreview’s Classic Sundaes begin with vanilla ice cream and a choice of hot fudge, butterscotch, or chocolate sauce. The menu lists whipped cream, chopped nuts, and a cherry as the finishing touches.
This is the most customizable dessert on the listed menu. One person may want the familiar richness of hot fudge, while another may prefer butterscotch or classic chocolate. It can also be an easy choice when the table wants a traditional supper club finish without needing to know the rotating dessert of the evening.
Cake or Pie of the Evening
The Cake or Pie of the Evening changes, so the current selection is something to ask about during your visit. Shoreview’s menu describes it as a rotating house-made cake or pie served with whipped cream, with an à la mode option available upon request.
Because the specific flavor is not fixed on the website, this choice adds a little surprise to the meal. If you are coming specifically for cake or pie, call before making the trip to confirm what is available that evening.
Old-Fashioned Malt
For a drinkable dessert, the current menu lists an Old-Fashioned Malt made with real ice cream. Chocolate and strawberry are the listed flavor choices, finished with whipped cream and a cherry.
A malt can work as the final course after dinner or as a nostalgic sweet treat on its own. It is also one of the menu’s most recognizably old-school options, fitting naturally into a relaxed Wisconsin supper club meal.
What does à la mode mean?
À la mode means adding a scoop of vanilla ice cream to a dessert. Shoreview lists this option for guests who want a warm-or-rich dessert paired with a cool, creamy finish. The live menu specifically notes that the evening’s cake or pie may be served à la mode upon request.
Which dessert should you choose?
- Choose a Classic Sundae when you want vanilla ice cream with your preferred sauce and traditional toppings.
- Ask about the Cake or Pie of the Evening when you like a rotating selection or want to see what is featured that night.
- Order an Old-Fashioned Malt when chocolate or strawberry sounds like the right finish.
- Ask for à la mode when adding vanilla ice cream sounds better than dessert on its own.
If more than one option sounds good, ask your server what is available and decide whether to share. Availability can vary, and the live dessert page remains the best online reference for the restaurant’s listed choices.
Plan a dessert finish near Pike Lake
Dessert can turn dinner into a longer, more relaxed outing—especially after seafood, a burger, Friday fish fry, or prime rib. Shoreview is located at 796 100th St in Amery near Pike Lake. Regular website hours list Wednesday through Saturday beginning at 4:00 PM, with Sunday brunch from 10:00 AM to 1:00 PM; Monday and Tuesday are closed.
Before visiting, browse the live dessert menu, explore the full menu directory, and check the location and current hours. For dessert availability or reservation questions, call 715-268-8774.
Call Shoreview to plan your visit
Representative dessert image; it does not depict the current cake or pie selection. Photo by Emma Houghton on Unsplash.